An editorial in today’s Wall Street Journal agrees that President Bush has full authority under the Constitution to order the U.S. military to depose Saddam Hussein. It argues, however, that under the logic of politics in a democracy, the President should seek approval from Congress. The Journal identifies practical advantages of doing so — to avoid being second-guessed on every decision if things get sticky (don’t count on that one); to compel greater political honesty by making members of Congress take a stand; and to clarify the administration’s own position through debate.
George Will, on the other hand, believes that congressional approval is not just a matter of prudence, but is also constitutionally required. He acknowledges that presidents have often used military force without such approval. But Will notes that these were not cases of a large engagement in the absence of a surprise attack. The reference to an attack may be an attempt to distinguish the current situation with Iraq from the Korean War, when the U.S. incurred more than 50,000 casualties in a drawn-out action that Congress never approved. The distinction is valid, but not necessarily of consititutional significance. In other words, it is not clear why, as a constitutional matter, waging a massive war to repel enemy aggression against a faraway nation does not require congressional authorization but launching a pre-emptive strike does.
The best case for going to Congress remains the prudential one.
Most Read on Power Line
- Why You Should Be Sympathetic Toward Cliven Bundy
- Today's IRS Documents: What Do They Show?
- Standoff at Bundy Ranch Ends, With Photo of the Year So Far
- The War On Standards Comes to College Debate [with comment by Paul]
- Is Scott Walker on his way to 2016 front-runner status?
- At Dartmouth, Phil Hanlon wants no enemies to the left
Subscribe to Power Line by Email
Find us on Facebook
“Arise and take our stand for freedom as in the olden time.” Winston Churchill
“Proclaim Liberty throughout All the land unto All the Inhabitants Thereof.” Inscription on the Liberty Bell