Reaction to Judge Roberts’ appointment from liberal bloggers hasn’t been all negative. David Schraub at the Debate Link has written a good piece. I’ve come across a few other fair-minded ones that I’ll link to later on if I find the time.
UPDATE: The excellent blog Southern Appeal links to several other liberal bloggers who have thus far taken a moderate position on Roberts. Legal Fiction is one. Another is L-cubed.
Less reasonable, it seems to me, is Ann Coulter’s complaint reported by Drudge that Roberts may not really be a conservative. Coulter cites the Souter debacle. But Souter was an unknown from New Hampshire whose conversatism was vouched for by John Sununu (conservative, but a politician, not an active lawyer) and Warren Rudman (not even a conservative). Roberts has been a player in Washington legal circles, including actively conservative ones, for more than two decades. And he has worked side-by-side with many of the leading conservative lawyers in D.C. in one or more Republican administrations. To my knowledge, none has a bad word to say about him. The fact that fair-minded liberals also respect him shouldn’t be considered a negative. (Maybe Roberts talked to them because he felt he “must”).
Roberts may not be as conservative as a few who reportedly were on Bush’s list. And a longer track record as a judge would have been nice. But it’s unfair to suggest that Roberts is or will be anything like Souter. A comparison to Rehnquist would be far more apt. Indeed, while Coulter contends that “stealth” nominees “never” work out, I don’t recall Rehnquist, plucked by Nixon from the Justice Department, having a more substantial track record than Roberts can point to.
JOHN adds: Ann is just wrong about this one. Frankly, it’s hard to believe she’s serious. Calling John Roberts a “stealth” candidate is ridiculous; he has been on everyone’s short list of preferred conservatives, along with Michael Luttig and Michael McConnell, for a long time. When David Souter was nominated, we–and conservatives everywhere–said, “David who?” When Roberts was nominated, we broke out the bubbly. Ann occasionally goes a bit overboard, but I can’t remember a time when she has been this totally misguided, and, as I said, I have a hard time believing she’s serious. Maybe, as Roger Simon suggests, it’s triangulation.
- Subscribe now!... Get rid of ADs!Support Power Line...VIP MembershipPresentsPower Line
Most Read on Power Line
Subscribe to Power Line by Email
Find us on Facebook
“Arise and take our stand for freedom as in the olden time.” Winston Churchill
“Proclaim Liberty throughout All the land unto All the Inhabitants Thereof.” Inscription on the Liberty Bell