Tom Cotton nails it on the AHCA

Sen. Tom Cotton announced today that he will not vote for the American Health Care Act in its present form. He released the following statement:

Despite the proposed amendments, I still cannot support the House health-care bill, nor would it pass the Senate. The amendments improve the Medicaid reforms in the original bill, but do little to address the core problem of Obamacare: rising premiums and deductibles, which are making insurance unaffordable for too many Arkansans.

The House should continue its work on this bill. It’s more important to finally get health-care reform right than to get it fast.

(Emphasis added)

Exactly. Medicaid reforms, notably the imposition of a work requirement for certain recipients, are desirable, but peripheral. It’s all about the premiums and the deductibles.

If, under a Republican plan, premiums/deductibles continue to rise, people will believe that Obamacare’s replacement made things worse. They will blame Republicans and the GOP will pay a heavy price.

No Republican should support replacement legislation unless he or she is confident it will result in better outcomes with regard to premiums/deductibles. If Democrats won’t support legislation that’s likely to produce that result, Republicans should either push such legislation through without Democratic support (overruling the Senate parliamentarian) if necessary or let such legislation be voted down.

Republicans have no obligation to pass replacement legislation they don’t like in order to patch up Obamacare. The Democrats created the current mess. If they won’t cooperate with the GOP in fixing it properly, Republicans shouldn’t take the political hit that would come with pretending to fix it on their own.

Responses

Books to read from Power Line